is nominal data qualitative or quantitativerick roll emoji copy and paste

For example, height can be measures in the number of inches for everyone. It's scaleable and automation-friendly. This is sometimes called "attribute data", but it's type is nominal (aka categorical etc). And this is only one approach from Stanley Smith Stevens. Try to identify additional data sets in this example. As we've discussed, nominal data is a categorical data type, so it describes qualitative characteristics or groups, with no order or rank between categories. Requested URL: byjus.com/maths/types-of-data-in-statistics/, User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; CPU iPhone OS 15_3_1 like Mac OS X) AppleWebKit/605.1.15 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/15.3 Mobile/15E148 Safari/604.1. These categories help us deciding which encoding strategy can be applied to which type of data. The success of such data-driven solutions requires a variety of data types. Legal. Statistics and Probability questions and answers, Is this data quantitative or qualitative and then chose if its continuous, discrete, ordinal or nominal 2. How is nominal data different from ordinal data? Data encoding for Qualitative data is important because machine learning models cant handle these values directly and needed to be converted to numerical types as the models are mathematical in nature. These types of data are sorted by category, not by number. Short story taking place on a toroidal planet or moon involving flying. 8 Ways Data Science Brings Value to the Business, The Ultimate Data Science Cheat Sheet Every Data Scientists Should Have, Top 6 Reasons Why You Should Become a Data Scientist. The Nominal and Ordinal data types are classified under categorical, while interval and ratio data are classified under numerical. By clicking Post Your Answer, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. Numerical data, on the other hand, is mostly collected through multiple-choice questions whenever there is a need for calculation. Yes, the weights are quantitative data because weight is a numerical variable that is measured. . Qualitative/nominal variables name or label different categories of objects. Nominal data is also called the nominal scale. Cross Validated is a question and answer site for people interested in statistics, machine learning, data analysis, data mining, and data visualization. nominal and ordinal Qualitative Data Attributes, labels, or non-numerical entries Quantitative Data Numerical measurements or counts The 4 Levels of Measurement 1. Python | How and where to apply Feature Scaling? Examples of nominal data include: Gender, ethnicity, eye colour, blood type Brand of refrigerator/motor vehicle/television owned 0 l Qualitative data is typically words, but could also be images or other media, we will refer to this data in this course as categorical. Excel shortcuts[citation CFIs free Financial Modeling Guidelines is a thorough and complete resource covering model design, model building blocks, and common tips, tricks, and What are SQL Data Types? In other words, the qualitative approach refers to information that describes certain properties, labels, and attributes. The number of steps in a stairway, Discrete or Continuous For a customer, object attributes can be customer Id, address, etc. i appreciate your help. Qualitative types of data in research work around the characteristics of the retrieved information and helps understand customer behavior. If, voter-names are known, and, it holds voter-names, then variable is nominal. The branch of statistics that involves using a sample to draw . d. How many of these presidents belonged to the Whig Party? 20152023 upGrad Education Private Limited. does not have a number. Binary is also a characteristic of type (it is a subset of discrete). Experts are tested by Chegg as specialists in their subject area. Use MathJax to format equations. Neither of these charts are correct. The ordering does not matter in nominal data, but it does in ordinal Interval and ratio are quantitative data that represent a magnitude Attribute:It can be seen as a data field that represents the characteristics or features of a data object. in Dispute Resolution from Jindal Law School, Global Master Certificate in Integrated Supply Chain Management Michigan State University, Certificate Programme in Operations Management and Analytics IIT Delhi, MBA (Global) in Digital Marketing Deakin MICA, MBA in Digital Finance O.P. Quantitative (Numeric, Discrete, Continuous). This type of data in statistics helps run market analysis through genuine figures and create value out of service by implementing useful information. For example, information collected through yes or no closed questions is a type of nominal data: would you recommend this product?. As a result of the EUs General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). When we ask ourselves why data science is essential, the answer rests because the value of data continues to increase. If the average rate of change of a linear function is 23,\frac{2}{3},32, then if y increases by 3, x will increase by 2. In simple terms, data is a systematic record of digital information retrieved from digital interactions as facts and figures. The etymology of data is here revealing: translating the original Latin literally, they are as given to you, but there is no rule against converting them to many other forms. You may use market reports, conduct surveys, or collect web scraped data that can be transposed into numbers with certain values. There are many different types of qualitative data, like data in research, work, and statistics. Book a Session with an industry professional today! Interested parties can collect these data directly from the source (i.e., social media platforms), or utilize web data providers. \text { R } & \text { D } & \text { R } & \text { D } & \text { R } & \text { R } & \text { R } & \text { D } & \text { R } & \text { R } On the one hand, there is traditional data, or internal data, produced by a particular company. acknowledge that you have read and understood our, Data Structure & Algorithm Classes (Live), Data Structure & Algorithm-Self Paced(C++/JAVA), Android App Development with Kotlin(Live), Full Stack Development with React & Node JS(Live), GATE CS Original Papers and Official Keys, ISRO CS Original Papers and Official Keys, ISRO CS Syllabus for Scientist/Engineer Exam, Understanding Data Attribute Types | Qualitative and Quantitative, Movie recommendation based on emotion in Python, Python | Implementation of Movie Recommender System, Item-to-Item Based Collaborative Filtering, Frequent Item set in Data set (Association Rule Mining). Determine whether the given number is a solution to the equation following it. For nominal data, hypothesis testing can be carried out using nonparametric tests such as the chi-squared test. The three main types of qualitative data are binary, nominal, and ordinal. Thus it is still under the qualitative umbrella. Qualitative questions focus more on social research design and textual answers from control groups so businesses can personalize content and products to better fit the target audience, among other things. So, how the data are first encoded rarely inhibits their use in other ways and transformation to other forms. The characteristics of individuals about which we collect information are called, Nominal or Ordinal You can think of these categories as nouns or labels; they are purely descriptive, they don't have any quantitative or numeric value, and the various categories cannot be placed into any kind of meaningful order or hierarchy. Overall, ordinal data have some order, but nominal data do not. It is often unstructured or semi-structured, and perhaps one of the easiest ways to identify it is that it does not come as numbers. There are a variety of ways that quantitative data arises in statistics. We could categorize variables according to the levels of measurement, then we could have 4 scales (groups) with the following rules: nominal: attributes of a variable are differentiated only by name (category) and there is no order (rank, position). Qualitative (Nominal (N), Ordinal (O), Binary (B)). When it comes to . Difference between qualitative and quantitative data. Qualitative variables are divided into two types: nominal and ordinal. Information coming from observations, counts, measurements, or responses. To get to know about the data it is necessary to discuss data objects, data attributes, and types of data attributes. A frequency distribution table should be prepared for these data. Nominal scales provide the least amount of detail. \text { F } & \text { F } & \text { DR } & \text { DR } & \text { DR } & \text { DR } & \text { D } & \text { D } & \text { W } & \text { W } \\ You sample the same five students. This data type is used just for labeling variables, without having any quantitative value. Something is either an apple or an orange, halfway between an apple and an orange doesn't mean anything. Quantitative data types in statistics contain a precise numerical value. These can take the form of the operating frequency of the processors, the android version of the phone, wifi frequency, temperature of the cores, and so on. In this article, we discussed how the data we produce can turn the tables upside down, how the various categories of data are arranged according to their need. The type of scale determines what specific statistical analysis you should use. Regression analysis, where the relationship between one dependent and two or more independent variables is analyzed is possible only for quantitative data. All this information can be categorized as Qualitative data. The differences between various classes are not clear therefore cant be quantified directly. According to Time magazine, some of the best fiction books in a recent year were: This data collection is facilitated via the interconnectivity of devices. When a data object is listed in a database they are called data tuples. Nominal, ordinal, interval, and ratio scales explained. Name data sets that are quantitative discrete, quantitative continuous, and qualitative. hb```g,aBAfk3: hh! Book a session with an industry professional today! The reviews are written by employees who work in the company, therefore it helps you assess the internal situation. What type of plot is suitable for which category of data was also discussed along with various types of test that can be applied on specific data type and other tests that uses all types of data. Is it suspicious or odd to stand by the gate of a GA airport watching the planes? By providing your email address you agree to receive newsletters from Coresignal. Qualitative data may be labeled with numbers allowing this . Statistics and Probability. Such scoring is the basis of all sorts of analyses: the proportion female is just the average of several 0s for males and 1s for females. Data that is used to label variables without providing quantitative values. The variable is qualitative, to be precise is nominal. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. This pie chart shows the students in each year, which is qualitative data. Nominal data is a type of qualitative data which groups variables into categories. Page 17 Qualitative research is based more on subjective views, whereas quantitative research shows objective numbers. List of Excel Shortcuts Is this data quantitative or qualitative and then chose if its continuous, discrete, ordinal or nominal Counting the number of patients with breast cancer in a clinic ( study recorded at random intervals throughout the year) Quantitative variables. There are 3 fundamental variable types (excluding subtypes): Nominal (categorical/qualitative), Ordinal, and Continuous (Numeric, Quantitative). This is the First step of Data-preprocessing. More objective and accurate since it's expressed in numbers; Easier to categorize, organize, and analyze; Suitable for statistical analysis and AI-based processes; Sometimes one type of research complements the other. There are four levels of measurement (or scales) to be aware of: nominal, ordinal, interval, and ratio. Likewise, quantitative data is oftentimes favored due to the ease of processing, collection, and integration. By numerising the categories, it appears to "quantitativise" them even though strictly they a. Structured data is formatted and organized for readability within relational databases. Binary is rarely ordered, and almost always is represented by nominal variables. Global Doctor of Business Administration SSBM, Master of Business Administration (MBA) LBS and IMT, MBA (Global) Deakin Business School and IMT, Master of Science in Machine Learning & AI LJMU and IIIT-B, Advanced Certification in Machine Learning and Cloud IIT-M, Executive PG Program in Machine Learning & AI IIIT-B, Advanced Certificate Program in Machine Learning and Deep Learning IIIT-B, Advanced Certificate Program in Machine Learning and NLP IIIT-B, Master of Science in Machine Learning & AI LJMU and IIT-M, Master of Science in Data Science LJMU and IIIT-B, Executive PG Program in Data Science IIIT-B, Professional Certificate Program in Data Science and BA University of Maryland, Caltech CTME Data Analytics Certificate Program powered by Fullstack Academy and upGrad, Advanced Certificate Program in Data Science IIIT-B, Advanced Program in Data Science IIIT-B, Professional Certificate Program in Data Science for Business Decision Making IIM-K, Marketing Analytics Certificate Program Emory University, Advanced Certificate in Digital Marketing and Communication MICA and upGrad, Full Stack Development Certificate Program Purdue University, Master of Science in Computer Science LJMU and IIIT-B, Caltech CTME Cybersecurity Certificate Program powered by Fullstack Academy and upGrad, Executive PG Program in Software Development IIIT-B, Advanced Certificate Program in Cloud Backend Development IIIT-B, Advanced Certificate Program in DevOps IIIT-B, Advanced Certificate Program in Cyber Security IIIT-B, Advanced Certificate Program in Big Data IIIT-B, Blockchain Certificate Program Purdue University, Cloud Backend Development Certificate Program Purdue University, Product Management Certification Program Duke CE, Project Management Professional (PMP) Certification Course upGrad Knowledgehut, Certified ScrumMaster (CSM) Course upGrad Knowledgehut, M.Sc in Data Science LJMU & IIIT Bangalore, Importance of Qualitative and Quantitative Data. The political party of each of the first 30 American presidents is revealed in the statistics below. Qualitative Variables. Learn what qualitative data is and explore 26 examples of qualitative data in various situations to help you improve your research and analytical skills. There is an aggregation to counts (how many such deaths in a area and a time period), a reduction to rates (how many relative to the population at risk), and so on. Interval Level 4. We can say that a set of attributes used to describe a given object are known as attribute vector or feature vector. 133 0 obj <> endobj By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. Dr. MO isn't sharing this to scare you, but to show how important knowing the type of variable will be when analyzing data statistically. Answer (1 of 7): An Ordinal variable assigns number "ranks" to an otherwise categorical data. Overview of Scaling: Vertical And Horizontal Scaling, SDE SHEET - A Complete Guide for SDE Preparation, Linear Regression (Python Implementation), Software Engineering | Coupling and Cohesion. For companies, data science is a significant resource for making data-driven decisions since it describes the collecting, saving, sorting, and evaluating data. Our learners also read: Excel online course free! This is because this information can be easily categorized based on properties or certain characteristics., The main feature is that qualitative data does not come as numbers with mathematical meaning, but rather as words. Determine the percentage and relative frequency distributions. If, voter-names are known, and, it holds voter-names, then variable is nominal. Qualitative data is generated via numerous channels, such as company employee reviews, in-depth interviews, and focus groups, to name a few. No tracking or performance measurement cookies were served with this page. When this happens with qualitative variables, the results are junk. It is also known as the nominal scale. These data consist of audio, images, symbols, or text. The truth is that it is still ordinal. Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. Discrete data is often identified through charts, including bar charts, pie charts, and tally charts. Some other benefits and applications of such web data include: The second major type of data is quantitative. How can we prove that the supernatural or paranormal doesn't exist? The gender of a person (male, female, or others) is a good example of this data type. In the data, D stands for Democrat, DR for Democratic Republican, F for Federalist, R for Republican, and W for Whig. It means that this type of data cant be counted or measured easily using numbers and therefore divided into categories. You can gather insights into the company's well-being regarding employee Unlock new business opportunities with Coresignal. Develop analytical superpowers by learning how to use programming and data analytics tools such as VBA, Python, Tableau, Power BI, Power Query, and more. Jindal Global University, Product Management Certification Program DUKE CE, PG Programme in Human Resource Management LIBA, HR Management and Analytics IIM Kozhikode, PG Programme in Healthcare Management LIBA, Finance for Non Finance Executives IIT Delhi, PG Programme in Management IMT Ghaziabad, Leadership and Management in New-Age Business, Executive PG Programme in Human Resource Management LIBA, Professional Certificate Programme in HR Management and Analytics IIM Kozhikode, IMT Management Certification + Liverpool MBA, IMT Management Certification + Deakin MBA, IMT Management Certification with 100% Job Guaranteed, Master of Science in ML & AI LJMU & IIT Madras, HR Management & Analytics IIM Kozhikode, Certificate Programme in Blockchain IIIT Bangalore, Executive PGP in Cloud Backend Development IIIT Bangalore, Certificate Programme in DevOps IIIT Bangalore, Certification in Cloud Backend Development IIIT Bangalore, Executive PG Programme in ML & AI IIIT Bangalore, Certificate Programme in ML & NLP IIIT Bangalore, Certificate Programme in ML & Deep Learning IIIT B, Executive Post-Graduate Programme in Human Resource Management, Executive Post-Graduate Programme in Healthcare Management, Executive Post-Graduate Programme in Business Analytics, LL.M. Examples include clinical trials or censuses. Numerical attributes are of 2 types, interval, and ratio. Is the month ordinal or nominal variable? Leaning. Discrete quantitative 3. Data Objects are like a group of attributes of an entity. Numeric: A numeric attribute is quantitative because, it is a measurable quantity, represented in integer or real values. Nominal or Ordinal The number of speakers in the phone, cameras, cores in the processor, the number of sims supported all these are some of the examples of the discrete data type. Is it plausible for constructed languages to be used to affect thought and control or mold people towards desired outcomes? If I encounter 7 females and 3 males, I can just average 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0, 0, 0 to get the proportion 0.7. A statistics professor collects information about the classification of her students as freshmen, sophomores, juniors, or seniors. It is a major feature of case studies. Nominal. Qualitative means you can't, and it's not numerical (think quality - categorical data instead). Nominal data is labelled into mutually exclusive categories within a variable. The proportion male is just 1 minus the proportion female, and so forth. I would consider discrete a quality of type, not a type itself. The Registrar keeps records of the number of credit hours students complete each semester. No one need get worried by the coding being arbitrary. In some cases, qualitative data may be assigned numbers (1 or 0, for instance) for analysis purposes.. What is another example of a qualitative variable? Just like nominal data, this can also be used to calculate percentages, proportions, and frequencies, among others., Qualitative data helps you understand the reasons behind certain phenomena. Data science can be found just about anywhere these days. An example will be the measures of level of agreement of respondents to a thesis as we see in a Likert Scale. Data science's effect has grown dramatically due to its advancements and technical advancements, expanding its scope. +M"nfp;xO?<3M4 Q[=kEw.T;"|FmWE5+Dm.r^ Categorical data is a data type that is not quantitative i.e. In this way, you can apply the Chi-square test on qualitative data to discover relationships between categorical variables. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); document.getElementById( "ak_js_2" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); UPGRAD AND IIIT-BANGALORE'S EXECUTIVE PG PROGRAM IN DATA SCIENCE. These are usually extracted from audio, images, or text medium. Why are physically impossible and logically impossible concepts considered separate in terms of probability? Nominal : Ordinal : Meaning In this scale, the data is grouped according to their names. Qualitative variables, which are the nominal Scale of Measurement, have different values to represent different categories or kinds. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Mandata, all these charts from different experts are partly correct. They seem to be conflating the ideas of fundamental variable type and variable selection to model a system (with a pdf). If it holds number of votes, the variable is quantitative, to be precise is in ratio scale. Get Free career counselling from upGrad experts! We also looked at how ordinal data types can overlap with the discrete data types. Is it possible to create a concave light? Must Read:Data Scientist Salary in India. Some researchers call the first two scales of measurement (Ratio Scale and Interval Scale) quantitative because they measure things numerically, and call the last scale of measurement (Nominal Scale) qualitative because you count the number of things that have that quality. We have discussed all the major classifications of Data. For example, a company's financial reports contain quantitative data. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? The benefit of choosing a data provider is that the information is already selected and presented in an easy-to-understand format, rather than collecting all the data available on all social media platforms or search engines. All these things have one common driving component and this is Data. The categories Strongly disagree, Disagree, Neutral, Agree, and Strongly agree on a survey, Nominal or Ordinal Nominal data cannot be ordered and measured. rev2023.3.3.43278. Nominal and ordinal are categorical(or qualitative) data, ie values that do not represent a magnitude. Here, the term 'nominal' comes from the Latin word "nomen" which means 'name'. On the other hand, the Quantitative data types of statistical data work with numerical values that can be measured, answering questions such as how much, how many, or how many times. Regards, Leaning. A numerical description of a population characteristic. Unlike discrete data types of data in research, with a whole and fixed value, continuous data can break down into smaller pieces and can take any value. For example, the variable gender is nominal because there is no order in the levels female/male. The composition of the bar has been slightly modified, but the modification is not believed to have affected either the normality or the value of \sigma. Another example can be of a smartphone brand that provides information about the current rating, the color of the phone, category of the phone, and so on. Exercise \(\PageIndex{3}\) shows that variables can be defined in different ways. Categorical data can be further split into nominal or ordinal data. Data objects are the essential part of a database. On the other hand, various types of qualitative data can be represented in nominal form. When we do the categorization we define the rules for grouping the objects according to our purpose. Mining data includes knowing about data, finding relations between data. Types of statistical data work as an insight for future predictions and improving pre-existing services. Qualitative types of data in statistics can drastically affect customer satisfaction if applied smartly. Quantitative (Numeric, Discrete, Continuous) Qualitative Attributes: 1. Qualitative and quantitative data are much different, but bring equal value to any data analysis. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. By using our site, you q3_v]Yz>],-w~vziG4}zgO6F+:uM"Ige&n EN"m&W7)i&e\xU-7iU!% ]4b[wD*}1*?zG>?/*+6+EuYVnI+]p kpu+bZ7ix?Ec UB`+(Yez6"=;l&&M -0"n 4?R.K]~)C9QGB$ l=8 6=0_i38|e_=\rc g~$A>=mbLnleJk'ks6\BsE{&*:x )R1Bk04/En7~)+*A'M The price of a smartphone, discount offered, number of ratings on a product, the frequency of processor of a smartphone, or ram of that particular phone, all these things fall under the category of Quantitative data types. It helps create a story, develop hypotheses, or obtain an initial understanding of a case or situation.. Is the weight of the backpacks a quantitative variable? When we talk about data mining, we usually discuss knowledge discovery from data. Updated on February 27, 2018 In statistics, quantitative data is numerical and acquired through counting or measuring and contrasted with qualitative data sets, which describe attributes of objects but do not contain numbers. However, all data types fall under one of two categories: qualitative and quantitative. Nominal data do not provide any quantitative value, and you cannot perform numeric operations with them or compare them with one another. An ordinal data type is similar to a nominal one, but the distinction between the two is an obvious ordering in the data. How can I combine nominal with ordinal data to build a unique variable? Nominal Data. Factor analysis on mixed (continuous/ordinal/nominal) data? See. The variable is nominal: It's only names, there is no order to it. Qualitative research is best when the goal is to collect data about a product's or service's satisfaction between users. Qualitative variables are counted, and the counts are used in statistical analyses.The name or label of a qualitative variable can be a number, but the number doesnt mean anything. Dissimilar to interval or ratio data, nominal data cannot be manipulated using available mathematical operators. Examples of nominal data are letters, symbols, words . Discrete or Continuous [It turns out that there are a LOT of videos online about statistics! We differentiate between different types of attributes and then preprocess the data. For instance, the price of a smartphone can vary from x amount to any value and it can be further broken down based on fractional values. endstream endobj 137 0 obj <>stream Professional Certificate in Data Science from IIM K, Data Science for Managers from IIM Kozhikode - Duration 8 Months, Executive PG Program in Data Science from IIIT-B - Duration 12 Months, Master of Science in Data Science from LJMU - Duration 18 Months, Executive Post Graduate Program in Data Science and Machine LEarning - Duration 12 Months, Master of Science in Data Science from University of Arizona - Duration 24 Months, Master of Science in Data Science IIIT Bangalore, Executive PG Programme in Data Science IIIT Bangalore, Master of Science in Data Science LJMU & IIIT Bangalore, Advanced Certificate Programme in Data Science, Caltech CTME Data Analytics Certificate Program, Advanced Programme in Data Science IIIT Bangalore, Professional Certificate Program in Data Science and Business Analytics, Cybersecurity Certificate Program Caltech, Blockchain Certification PGD IIIT Bangalore, Advanced Certificate Programme in Blockchain IIIT Bangalore, Cloud Backend Development Program PURDUE, Cybersecurity Certificate Program PURDUE, Msc in Computer Science from Liverpool John Moores University, Msc in Computer Science (CyberSecurity) Liverpool John Moores University, Full Stack Developer Course IIIT Bangalore, Advanced Certificate Programme in DevOps IIIT Bangalore, Advanced Certificate Programme in Cloud Backend Development IIIT Bangalore, Master of Science in Machine Learning & AI Liverpool John Moores University, Executive Post Graduate Programme in Machine Learning & AI IIIT Bangalore, Advanced Certification in Machine Learning and Cloud IIT Madras, Msc in ML & AI Liverpool John Moores University, Advanced Certificate Programme in Machine Learning & NLP IIIT Bangalore, Advanced Certificate Programme in Machine Learning & Deep Learning IIIT Bangalore, Advanced Certificate Program in AI for Managers IIT Roorkee, Advanced Certificate in Brand Communication Management, Executive Development Program In Digital Marketing XLRI, Advanced Certificate in Digital Marketing and Communication, Performance Marketing Bootcamp Google Ads, Data Science and Business Analytics Maryland, US, Executive PG Programme in Business Analytics EPGP LIBA, Business Analytics Certification Programme from upGrad, Business Analytics Certification Programme, Global Master Certificate in Business Analytics Michigan State University, Master of Science in Project Management Golden Gate Univerity, Project Management For Senior Professionals XLRI Jamshedpur, Master in International Management (120 ECTS) IU, Germany, Advanced Credit Course for Master in Computer Science (120 ECTS) IU, Germany, Advanced Credit Course for Master in International Management (120 ECTS) IU, Germany, Master in Data Science (120 ECTS) IU, Germany, Bachelor of Business Administration (180 ECTS) IU, Germany, B.Sc.

Where To Buy Fiddler Crabs For Bait, How To Remove Skylight From A Caravan, 2017 Chevy Malibu Auto Stop Problems, Jeffrey Stewart Obituary, Ahenobarbus Henocied Face Origin, Articles I